| Cináeth Ua Baígill | ( – 1135) | |
| Gilla Críst Ua Morgair | (1135 – 1138) | |
| Áed Ua Cáellaide | (1138 – 1178) | |
| Mael Ísu Ua Cerbaill | (1178 – 1186/7) | |
| Gilla Críst Ua Mucaráin | (c.1187 – 1193) | |
| Máel Ísu Ua Máel Chiaráin | (1194 – 1197) | |
| Gilla Tigernaig Mac Gilla Rónáin | (c.1197 – 1218) | |
| Donatus Ó Fidabra | (c.1218 – c.1227) | |
| Nehemias Ó Brácáin | (1227 – 1240) | |
| David Ó Brácáin | (c.1245 – 1267) | |
| Michael Mac an tSáir | (1268 – 1287) | |
| Matthaeus Mac Cathasaig I | (1287 – 1310) | |
| Henricus | (fl.1310 – c.1316) | |
| Gelasius alias Cornelius Ó Bánáin | (c.1316 – 1319) | |
| Nicolaus Mac Cathasaigh | (1320 – 1356) | |
| Brian Mac Cathmhaoil | (1356 – 1358) | |
| Matthaeus Mac Cathasaigh II | (c.1361 – ) | |
| Aodh Ó hEóthaigh (alias Ó Neill) | ( – 1369) | |
| Johannes Ó Corcráin | (1373 – c.1389) | |
| Art Mac Cathmhaoil | (1390 – 1432) | |
| Piaras Mag Uidhir | (1433 – 1447) | |
| Rossa mac Tomáis Óig Mág Uidhir | (1450 – 1483) | |
| Florence Woolley | (1475 – 1500) | Did not get possession |
| Niall mac Séamuis Mac Mathghamhna | (1484 – 1488) | Bulls not expedited |
| John Edmund de Courcy | (1484 – 1494) | |
| Séamus mac Pilib Mac Mathghamhna | (1494 – 1503) | Did not take effect |
| Andreas | (1500 – ) | |
| Nehemias Ó Cluainín | (1502 – 1503) | |
| Giolla Pádraig Ó Condálaigh | (1504 – 1504) | |
| Eoghan Mac Cathmhaoil | (1505 – 1515) | |
| Pádraig Ó Cuilín | (1517 – 1534) | |
| Hugh O’Carolan | (1537 – 1569) | |
| Raymond MacMahon1 | (1546 – 1560) | |
| Cornelius MacArdel1 | (1560 – c.1592) | |
| Eugene Matthews | (1609 – 1611) | |
| Heber MacMahon | (1643 – 1650) | |
| Patrick Duffy | (1671 – 1675) | |
| Patrick Tyrrell | (1676 – 1689) | |
| Hugh MacMahon | (1707 – 1715) | |
| Bernard MacMahon | (1718 – 1737) | |
| Ross MacMahon | (1738 – 1747) | |
| Daniel O’Reilly | (1747 – 1778) | |
| Hugh O’Reilly | (1778 – 1801) | |
| James Murphy | (1801 – 1824) | |
| Edward Kernan | (1824 – 1844) | |
| Charles MacNally | (1844 – 1864) | |
| James Donnelly | (1865 – 1893) | |
| Richard Owens | (1894 – 1909) | |
| Patrick McKenna | (1909 – 1942) | |
| Eugene O’Callaghan | (1943 – 1969) | |
| Patrick Mulligan | (1970 – 1979) | |
| Joseph Duffy | (1979 – ) |
